English 101 Section 16
Exotic Pets: Companions or Danger?
The relationship between humans and animals is one of the most remarkable examples of coexistence on Earth. For some people, pets are more than an animal that they take care of and live with; pets are members of the family. Many people have at one point or another owned a cat, dog, hamster, or even an ant farm. However, some people have found companions in more unusual animals such as lions, snakes, and exotic birds. Lauren Slater in “Wild Obsession,” published in the National Geographic periodical, gives a frightening example of exotic pet ownership gone wrong. Slater tells the story of Terry Thompson, an exotic pet owner in Zanesville, Ohio. Before committing suicide, Thompson put the entire community at risk by letting his 50 wild animals, including lions, out of their enclosures (Slater 103). Thompson’s story may be an extreme example but stories like his have led to discussion and legislation on what makes a good pet. Are exotic animals appropriate as pets, or are there too many true risks, consequences, and needs of nontraditional pets?
There are many ways to look at what an exotic pet is. With exotics being in sanctuaries, zoos, owned privately by individuals, and for entertainment purposes, one definition of “exotic pets” will not cover the different cases and circumstances. Amy B. Worell, doctor of veterinary medicine (DVM) states in the discussion “Exotic Animals: Appropriately Owned Pets or Inappropriately Kept Problems?” which was printed in the Journal of Avian Medicine and Surgery, “My definition of exotic animals . . . is any animal other than a dog or cat” (51). Worell’s definition makes sense from a biological standpoint. Most traditional pets tend to be cute, fuzzy mammals. With a more recent shared ancestry to humans, there are more common traits/characteristics so wild tendencies are more easily understood in addition to easier training based on experience. For example, both children and puppies respond well to positive reinforcement as a “potty training technique,” due to shared memory pathways in the brain. However, Dr. Worell’s definition infers that only mammals make good pets. In the same discussion, Dr. Orlando Figueroa-Diaz, also a DVM, makes a distinction: “I personally classify exotic animals as either companion exotic pets or wild exotic pets” (Hess 51). Dr. Figueroa-Diaz’s definition makes a good point that is corroborated by Dr. Jose Biascoechea: “The definition of what is an exotic pet versus an exotic animal needs to be clarified” (Hess 52). By this definition, Mr. Thompson in the opening story would be a wild exotic pet owner, despite owning a mammal. Whether or not Mr. Thompson saw his lions and other animals as companions, the animals were wild and undomesticated.
The distinction can be blurred. Due to sensationalism, it is easy to find examples of stories similar to Mr. Thompson, where wild exotic animals are presented as exotic pets. A 4-year-old mauled by his aunt’s pet mountain lion, a pet chimpanzee attacking a friend’s face, a famous Vegas act with a seemingly well-trained lion mauling his trainer to death are just a few examples of how exotic animals can be a danger to both humans and themselves. And the risks are not just from mammals; a 34 year old man was strangled by his pet snake (Slater 101).
Are these examples a minority or a true risk? Carlos Drews in “Wild Animals and Other Pets Kept in Costa Rican Househoulds: Incidence, Species and Numbers” published in the academic journal Society and Animals reports, “In a sample of U.S. Students, 22.5% reported keeping wild animals at home” (108). Drews also reported that of a 1,021 person sample in Costa Rican households, 33.3% of the 721 pet owners kept wild species (112). Based on these seemingly low statistics, it is easy to disregard the danger of these animals. However, that is still over 200 households with wild, undomesticated animals living with them. Stories like Mr. Thompson’s are a good reminder that even one person owning wild animals can be a risk for the entire community, especially for neighbors who are more likely to encounter the animals.
A retrospective study done in Europe, specifically Germany and France, supports the norm of wild animals and the consequences. In this study, reported in the academic journal Clinical Toxicology by Andreas Schaper and associates, all the bites and stings reported at four poison control centers over a ten year period were categorized based on age of victim, animals responsible for the injury and severity of injury. Of the 404 cases reported, almost all occurred in private households. The majority of bites were from snakes including rattlesnakes, green pit vipers, cobras and green mambas. The second most common bite or sting was from aquatic animals like stingrays or lionfish. Although a majority of the cases were determined to be minor and no fatalities were reported, the study still shows how some animals can be dangerous, and proper precautions need to be enforced. One of the goals of the study was to make known what types of antivenoms should be readily available, as time is a large factor in snake bites in particular. By having the study done reactively may make some disregard its information but really the findings are to the contrary. The fact that the cases were reported to poison control means they were moderate; reports of severe cases would mostly likely be found at hospitals so the estimations on this study are probably lower than the true number of bites and stings for this area (Schaper 40).
Aside from the more obvious dangers some exotic animals present, there are other lesser known consequences of non-native animals living in a new habitat. In the academic journal Emerging Infectious Diseases, Bruno B. Chomel and his associates points out, “Wildlife trade provides mechanisms for disease transmission at levels that not only cause human disease outbreaks but also threaten livestock, international trade, rural livelihoods, native wildlife populations, and ecosystem health” (7-8). One of the most well-known ecological consequences comes from Florida where non-native snakes have been released into the environment, dramatically changing the ecosystem and balance of life in the Everglades. These snakes were introduced to Florida by exotic pet owners who either lost their snakes or intentionally released them into the wilderness, usually due to not being able to care for them anymore. As Chomel notes, “Translocation of wild animals is associated with the spread of several zoonoses” (9). What he means by this is, like in the case of snakes in Florida, when wild animals are introduced to other environments, the animals bring along with them several diseases, parasites, fungi and other potentially harmful illnesses which can be devastating to the local organisms. The local organisms, which are not adapted to these dangers, can quickly die, upsetting the biodiversity of an area. These issues are not just limited to animals; as Chomel mentioned humans can get ill, too, in addition to having economic and food source disruption from the change in the ecosystem.
Based on all the presented evidence, it seems like exotic animals are never a good idea. However, as Dr. Brazelton mentions in the discussion “Exotic Animals: Appropriately Owned Pets or Inappropriately Kept Problems?” what really matters in any pet ownership: “We must weigh quality of life, safety, and long-term needs. As veterinarians, we need to guide clients and the general public as to which exotic animals may be successfully kept as pets and which exotic animals should not be ‘pets’” (50). The opinions of other doctors in the discussion range from “[n]ondomesticated exotic animals should not be kept as pets” (Dr. Rivera) to “[i]n the right hands and the right environment, all exotic animals are acceptable as pets” (Dr. Molnar) (Hess 52). Dr. Molnar, however, makes a distinction, “[A]ny species is okay if owners are knowledgeable, responsible, follow requirements, and respect the exotic pet’s welfare” (Hess 52).
Of the factors Dr. Molnar listed, all the doctors are unanimous on the most important factor in exotic pets: education. Part of that education needs to include knowing the limit of the animal and the caregiver. Despite the best of intentions and training, dealing with a wild, undomesticated animal is dangerous. Even domesticated animals can turn on his owner. Not all exotic animals will make good pets but not all are dangerous either. However, it is always good with any animal to know what could go wrong and have a what-if scenario in place before an emergency happens, which comes through education.
Another one of the limiting factors for proper exotic pet care is finances. Many exotic pets have special needs that can be costly. Regardless, the trend in the types of exotic pet owners reported by veterinarians in the discussion “The Effects of Economic Recession on Exotic Pet Practice” is that their clients see taking care of and providing for their exotic pet as a financial priority. As Dr. Driggers explains, “When a pet is a family member, people treat it whenever medical interventions are necessary” (Hess 354).
As with any pet, exotic animals can invoke strong emotions within humans who see the animals as companions. However, when there are safety issues and large scale consequences involved careful consideration of the needs of the animal and in depth education on what potential problems could arise are extremely important. Due to the variety of exotic animals, it is not an all or nothing phenomenon; not every animal can be a pet but that does not mean no one should own exotic pets. Each circumstance needs to be looked at individually. As long as needs of the animal are met and safety precautions enforced, some unusual animals can be an enriching addition to people’s lives.
Works Cited
Chomel, Bruno., et al. “Wildlife, Exotic Pets, and Emerging Zoonoses.” Emerging Infectious Diseases 13.1 (2007): 6-10. MasterFILE Premier. Web. 14 Nov. 2014.
Drews, Carlos. "Wild Animals And Other Pets Kept In Costa Rican Households: Incidence, Species And Numbers." Society & Animals 9.2 (2001): 107-126. Academic Search Complete. Web. 6 Nov. 2014.
Hess, Laurie., ed."The Effects of Economic Recession on Exotic Pet Practice." Journal of Avian Medicine & Surgery 22.4 (2008): 353-357. Academic Search Complete. Web. 6 Nov. 2014.
Hess, Laurie., ed."Exotic Animals: Appropriately Owned Pets Or Inappropriately Kept Problems?." Journal of Avian Medicine & Surgery 25.1 (2011): 50-56. Academic Search Complete. Web. 6 Nov. 2014.
Schaper, Andreas., et al. "Bites And Stings By Exotic Pets In Europe: An 11 Year Analysis Of 404 Cases From Northeastern Germany And Southeastern France." Clinical Toxicology (15563650) 47.1 (2009): 39-43. Academic Search Complete. Web. 6 Nov. 2014.
Slater, Lauren. "Wild Obsession." National Geographic 225.4 (2014): 96-119. Academic Search Complete. Web. 2 Nov. 2014.
"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"