THE DANGEROUS MORALITY OF MANAGING EARNINGS*

The Majority of Managers Surveyed Say It’s Not Wrong to Manage Earnings

Occasionally, the morals and ethics executives use to manage their businesses are examined and discussed. Unfortunately, the morals that guide the timing of nonoperating events and choices of accounting policies have largely been ignored. The ethical framework used by managers in reporting short-term earnings probably has received less attention than its operating counterpart because accountants prepare financial disclosures consistent with laws and generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP). Those disclosures are reviewed by objective auditors. Managers determine the short-term reported earnings of their companies by:

• Managing, providing leadership, and directing the use of resources in operations.

• Selecting the timing of some nonoperating events, such as the sale of excess assets or the placement of gains or losses into a particular reporting period.

• Choosing the accounting methods that are used to measure short-term earnings.

Casual observers of the financial reporting process may assume that time, laws, regulation, and professional standards have restricted accounting practices to those that are moral, ethical, fair, and precise. But most managers and their accountants know otherwise—that managing short-term earnings can be part of a manager’s job. To understand the morals of short-term earnings management, we surveyed general managers and finance, control, and audit managers. The results are frightening. We found striking disagreements among managers in all groups. Furthermore, the liberal definitions revealed in many responses of what is moral or ethical should raise profound questions about the quality of financial information that is used for decision-making purposes by parties both inside and outside a company. It seems many managers are convinced that if a practice is not explicitly prohibited or is only a slight deviation from rules, it is an ethical practice regardless of who might be affected either by the practice or the information that flows from it. This means that anyone who uses information on short-term earnings is vulnerable to misinterpretation, manipulation, or deliberate deception

The Morals of Managing Earnings

To find a “revealed” consensus concerning the morality of engaging in earnings-management activities, we prepared a questionnaire describing 13 earnings-management situations we had observed either directly or indirectly. The actions described in the incidents were all legal (although some were in violation of GAAP), but each could be construed as involving short-term earnings management.

A total of 649 managers completed our questionnaire. Table 2-1 classifies respondents by job function, and Table 2-2 summarizes the views on the acceptability of various earningsmanagement practices

A major finding of the survey was a striking lack of agreement. None of the respondent groups viewed any of the 13 practices unanimously as an ethical or unethical practice. The dispersion of judgments about many of the incidents was great. For example, here is one hypothetical earnings-management practice described in the questionnaire:

In September, a general manager realized that his division would need a strong performance in the last quarter of the year in order to reach its budget targets. He decided to implement a sales program offering liberal payment terms to pull some sales that would normally occur next year into the current year. Customers accepting delivery in the fourth quarter would not have to pay the invoice for 120 days.

The survey respondents’ judgments of the acceptability of this practice were distributed as follows:

Perhaps you are not surprised by these data. The ethical basis of an early shipment/ liberal payment program may not be something you have considered, but, with the prevalence of such diverse views, how can any user of a short-term earnings report know the quality of the information? Although the judgments about all earnings-management practices varied considerably, there are some other generalizations that can be made from the findings summarized in Table 2-2

• On average, the respondents viewed management of short-term earnings by accounting methods as significantly less acceptable than accomplishing the same ends by changing or manipulating operating decisions or procedures.

• The direction of the effect on earnings matters. Increasing earnings is judged less acceptable than reducing earnings.

• Materiality matters. Short-term earnings management is judged less acceptable if the earnings effect is large rather than small.

• The time period of the effect may affect ethical judgments. Managing short-term earnings at the end of an interim quarterly reporting period is viewed as somewhat more acceptable than engaging in the same activity at the end of an annual reporting period.

• The method of managing earnings has an effect. Increasing profits by offering extended credit terms is seen as less acceptable than accomplishing the same end by selling excess assets or using overtime to increase shipments.

Managers Interviewed

Were the survey results simply hypothetical, or did managers recognize they can manage earnings and choose to do so? To find the answers, we talked to a large number of the respondents. What they told us was rarely reassuring.

On accounting manipulations, a profit center controller reported:

A divisional general manager spoke to us about squeezing reserves to generate additional reported profit:

If we get a call asking for additional profit, and that’s not inconceivable, I would look at our reserves. Our reserves tend to be realistic, but we may have a product claim that could range from $50,000 to $500,000. Who knows what the right amount for something like that is? We would review our reserves, and if we felt some were on the high side, we would not be uncomfortable reducing them.

We also heard about operating manipulations. One corporate group controller noted:

[To boost sales] we have paid overtime and shipped on Saturday, the last day of the fiscal quarter. If we totally left responsibility for the shipping function to the divisions, it could even slip over to 12:30 A.M. Sunday. There are people who would do that and not know it’s wrong.

Managers often recognize that such actions “move” earnings from one period to another. For example, a division controller told us:

Last year we called our customers and asked if they would take early delivery. We generated an extra $300,000 in sales at the last minute. We were scratching for everything. We made our plans, but we cleaned out our backlog and started in the hole this year. We missed our first quarter sales plan. We will catch up by the end of the second quarter.

And a group vice president said:

I recently was involved in a situation where the manager wanted to delay the production costs for the advertising that would appear in the fall [so that he could meet his quarterly budget].

Thus, in practice, it appears that a large majority of managers use at least some methods to manage short-term earnings. Though legal, these methods do not seem to be consistent with a strict ethical framework. While the managers’ actions have the desired effect on reported earnings, the managers know there are no real positive economic benefits, and the actions might actually be quite costly in the long run. These actions are at best questionable because they involve deceptions that are not disclosed. Most managers who manage earnings, however, do not believe they are doing anything wrong.

We see two major problems. The most important is the generally high tolerance for operating manipulations. The other is the dispersion in managers’ views about which practices are moral and ethical.

The Dangerous Allure

The essence of a moral or an ethical approach to management is achieving a balance between individual interests and obligations to those who have a stake in what happens in the corporation (or what happens to a division or group within the corporation). These stakeholders include not only people who work in the firm, but customers, suppliers, creditors, shareholders, and investors as well.

Managers who take unproductive actions to boost short-term earnings may be acting totally within the laws and rules. Also, they may be acting in the best interest of the corporation. But if they fail to consider the adverse effects of their actions on other stakeholders, we may conclude that they are acting unethically.

The managers we interviewed explained that they rated accounting manipulations harshly because in such cases the “truth” has somehow been denied or misstated. The recipients of the earnings reports do not know what earnings would have been if no manipulation had taken place. Even if the accounting methods used are consistent with GAAP, they reason, the actions are not ethical because the interests of major stakeholder groups—including the recipients of the earnings reports—have been ignored.

The managers judge the operating manipulations more favorably because the earnings numbers are indicative of what actually took place. The operating manipulations have changed reality, and “truth” is fairly reported.

We see flaws in that reasoning. One is that the truth has not necessarily been disclosed completely. When sales and profits are borrowed from the future, for example, it is a rare company that discloses the borrowed nature of some of the profits reported. A second flaw in the reasoning about the acceptability of operating manipulations is that it ignores a few or all of the effects of some types of operating manipulations on the full range of stakeholders. Many managers consider operating manipulations as a kind of “victimless crime.” But victims do exist. Consider, for example, the relatively common operating manipulation of early shipments. As one manager told us:

Would I ship extra product if I was faced with a sales shortfall? You have to be careful there; you’re playing with fire. I would let whatever happened fall to the bottom line. I’ve been in companies that did whatever they could to make the sales number, such as shipping lower quality product. That’s way too short term. You have to draw the line there. You must maintain the level of quality and customer service. You’ll end up paying for bad shipments eventually. You’ll have returns, repairs, adjustments, ill will that will cause you to lose the account.… [In addition] it’s tough to go to your employees one day and say ship everything you can and then turn around the next day and say that the quality standards must be maintained.

Another reported:

We’ve had to go to [one of our biggest customers] and say we need an order. That kills us in the negotiations. Our last sale was at a price just over our cost of materials.

These comments point out that customers—and sometimes even the corporation—may be victims

Without a full analysis of the costs of operating manipulations, the dangers of such manipulations to the corporation are easily underestimated. Mistakes will be made because the quality of information is misjudged. The short term will be emphasized at the expense of the long term. If managers consistently manage short-term earnings, the messages sent to other employees create a corporate culture that lacks mutual trust, integrity, and loyalty.

A Lack of Moral Agreement

We also are troubled by the managers’ inability to agree on the types of earnings-management activities that are acceptable. This lack of agreement exists even within corporations.

What this suggests is that many managers are doing their analyses in different ways. The danger is obfuscation of the reality behind the financial reports. Because managers are using different standards, individuals who try to use the information reported may be unable to assess accurately the quality of that information

If differences in opinions exist, it is likely that financial reporting practices will sink to their lowest and most manipulative level. As a result, managers with strict definitions of what is moral and ethical will find it difficult to compete with managers who are not playing by the same rules. Ethical managers either will loosen their moral standards or fail to be promoted into positions of greater power.

Actions for Concerned Managers

We believe most corporations would benefit if they established clearer accounting and operating standards for all employees to follow. The standard-setting process should involve managers in discussions of the practices related to short-term earnings measurements. Until these standards are in place, different managers will use widely varying criteria in assessing the acceptability of various earnings-management practices. These variations will have an adverse effect on the quality of the firm’s financial information. Companies can use a questionnaire similar to the one in our study to encourage discussion and to communicate corporate standards and the reason for them. Standards also enable internal and external auditors and management to judge whether the desired quality of earnings is being maintained. In most companies, auditors can depend on good standards to identify and judge the acceptability of the operating manipulations. Ultimately, the line management chain-of-command, not auditors or financial staff, bears the primary responsibility for controlling operating manipulations. Often managers must rely on their prior experience and good judgment to distinguish between a decision that will have positive long-term benefits and one that has a positive short-term effect but a deleterious long-term effect. Finally, it is important to manage the corporate culture. A culture that promotes openness and cooperative problem solving among managers is likely to result in less short-term earnings management than one that is more competitive and where annual, and even quarterly, performance shortfalls are punished. A corporate culture that is more concerned with managing for excellence rather than for reporting short-term profits will be less likely to support the widespread use of immoral earnings-management practices.

Required

a. Time, laws, regulation, and professional standards have restricted accounting practices to those that are moral, ethical, fair, and precise. Comment.

b. Most managers surveyed had a conservative, strict interpretation of what is moral or ethical in financial reporting. Comment.

c. The managers surveyed exhibited a surprising agreement as to what constitutes an ethical or unethical practice. Comment.

d. List the five generalizations from the findings in this study relating to managing earnings.

e. Comment on management’s ability to manage earnings in the long run by influencing financial accounting.

"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!"

Comprehensive Problem 2 – Part 1: Taxpayer information, Form 1040, Schedule 1, Schedule 4, Schedule 5, Schedule A, and Schedule B

Gregory and Lulu Clifden’s Tax Return

Gregory R. and Lulu B. Clifden live with their family at the Rock Glen House Bed & Breakfast, which Gregory operates. The Bed & Breakfast (B&B) is located at 33333 Fume Blanc Way, Temecula, CA 92591. Gregory and Lulu enjoy good health and eyesight.

1. The Clifdens have three sons. Gerald is 17 years old, Gary is 12 years old, and Glenn is 10 years old. All three boys live at home and the Clifdens provide more than 50% of their support.

2. The Rock Glen House B&B is operated as a sole proprietorship and had the following income and expenses for the year:

All of the above amounts relate to the business portion of the Bed & Breakfast; the personal portion is accounted for separately. The Rock Glen House B&B uses the cash method of accounting and has no inventory. The employer tax ID number is 95-1234567.

3. The Clifdens made estimated federal income tax payments of $2,000 and estimated state income tax payments of $6,000 (all made during 2018).

4. Lulu worked about 1,000 hours as a substitute schoolteacher with the local school district. She also spent $276 out-of-pocket for various supplies for her classroom. Lulu’s Form W-2 from the school district is located on a separate tab.

5. Gregory is retired from the U.S. Navy. His annual statement from the Navy, Form 1099-R.

6. Gregory and Lulu paid (and can substantiate) the following amounts during the year:

During the year, Gregory and Lulu received the following qualifying dividends and interest:

7. Also, Lulu owns Series EE U.S. savings bonds. During the year, the bond redemption value increased by $1,300. Lulu has not elected the accrual method for these bonds. There were no Irish taxes paid on the interest from the Bank of Ireland. All the above stocks, bonds, and bank accounts are community property.

8. Lulu has a stock portfolio. During the year she sold stock, for which she received 1099-B Forms, as follows (basis was provided to the IRS in all cases):

9. Lulu paid her ex-husband $4,800 alimony in the current year, as required under the 2014 divorce decree. Her ex-husband’s name is Hector Leach and his Social Security number is 566-23-5431.

10. Gregory does all the significant work in the Bed & Breakfast and therefore he pays self-employment tax on 100 percent of the earnings from the B&B.

11. During the year, Gregory’s uncle Martin died. Martin had a $50,000 life insurance policy that named Gregory as the beneficiary. Gregory received the check for the benefits payable under the policy on November 30 of the current year. Martin also left Gregory a small nonoperating farm with an appraised value of $120,000.

12. Gregory is a general partner in a partnership that owns a boutique hotel in northern California and leases the property to a hotel management company. Gregory does not materially participate in the partnership activity but the partnership activity does rise to the level of a trade or business. See Schedule K-1 from the partnership.

13. Lulu was not eligible for health care benefits due to the part-time nature of her job thus health insurance for the Clifden household was purchased by Gregory. The Clifdens are not eligible for an exemption from coverage. The Clifdens purchased health insurance through the Covered California program and received the Form 1095-A. They had no other health insurance during 2018. Assume that the self-employed health insurance deduction is $1,540. The Clifdens did not claim an advance premium credit. Click here to access the completed Form 1095-A to use when completing Form 8962.

Required:
Gregory and Lulu have come to you to prepare their 2018 federal income tax return. You are not required to complete the state income tax return. Gregory and Lulu have given you several IRS forms (see 1099-B and 1099-INT) assumptions. Do not file a federal Form 4952.

• Click here to access the tax table for this problem.
• The taxpayers do not want to make a contribution to the presidential election campaign.
• Enter all amounts as positive numbers, except for a “loss.” If required, enter a “loss” as a negative number on the tax form.
• If an amount box does not require an entry or the answer is zero, enter “0”.
• If required, round your answers to the nearest dollar. On Schedule SE, use the rounded amounts in subsequent computations.
• Remember, the taxpayers make the election to include any child’s interest and dividends on their tax return.
• Make realistic assumptions about any missing data (addresses, etc.) that you may need.

The following is a list of the 13 forms and schedules that you will need to complete the tax return:

"Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!" https://graduatepaperhelp.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/logo-300x75-1.png 0 0 admin https://graduatepaperhelp.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/logo-300x75-1.png admin2021-04-19 14:22:142021-04-19 14:22:14Taxpayer information, Form 1040, Schedule 1, Schedule 4, Schedule 5, Schedule A, and Schedule... 1 answer below » Discuss which costs are relevant for the evaluation of this project and which costs are not…. April 19, 2021/in Uncategorized /by admin Your tasks: Based on the information in the case study, Catherine has asked you to write a report to TMR’s management advising them as to the best course of action regarding this project. Your report should address the following specific questions asked by TMR’s management: 1. Discuss which costs are relevant for the evaluation of this project and which costs are not. Your discussion should be justified by a valid argument and supported by references to appropriate sources 2. How are possible cannibalization and opportunity costs considered in this analysis? 3. Determine the initial investment cash flow. 4. Estimate all cash flows associated with the project over 5 years. It is assumed that where relevant, capital expenditures and marking costs are expended throughout the year, while cash flows relating to revenue and operating costs occur at the end of the year. You will need to broadly describe the method used for determining those cash flows. 5. Calculate the project’s payback period. Assuming the business will continue at the end of year 5 so ignore the possible terminal value of all assets (Car fleet and premises). Ignore the time value of money for this particular calculation. Briefly comment on your results 6. Estimate the Net present value (NPV) of the project, assuming that the initial investment is entirely funded by equity capital (retained earnings and new share issue). Assume further that the business could be sold at the end of the five years for $1 million. This figure includes the value of the car fleet, premises and capital gain from the business. Ignore any possible tax consequences of selling the business. Briefly comment on your results and make appropriate remarks on the assumptions made for these calculations if necessary. 7. Refer back to point 6, calculate the NPV of the project given that the project will be funded by 60% of debt and 40% of equity. Briefly explain the calculation of discount rate. Comments on the change in NPV between point 6 and point 7. 8. In view of your answer to Point 5 to point 7 above, advise TMR’s management as to whether they should go ahead with the investment project. In your recommendations, you may wish to suggest possible refinements in the method used for evaluating this project. Attachments: Assignment-in….pdf   "Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!" https://graduatepaperhelp.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/logo-300x75-1.png 0 0 admin https://graduatepaperhelp.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/logo-300x75-1.png admin2021-04-19 14:20:462021-04-19 14:20:46Discuss which costs are relevant for the evaluation of this project and which costs are not.... Consider two spin 1 particles, that can be combined to form j = 0, 1, 2 states. Use a method of… 1 answer below » April 19, 2021/in Uncategorized /by admin Consider two spin 1 particles, that can be combined to form j = 0, 1, 2 states. Use a method of your choosing to express the nine global eigenkets | j, m > in terms of the local eigenkets | j 1 , j 1 ; m 1 , m 2 > . Attachments: F5F1BA03-1CE6….jpeg   "Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!" https://graduatepaperhelp.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/logo-300x75-1.png 0 0 admin https://graduatepaperhelp.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/logo-300x75-1.png admin2021-04-19 14:20:242021-04-19 14:20:24Consider two spin 1 particles, that can be combined to form j = 0, 1, 2 states. Use a method of... 1 answer below » Choose a topic from the list provided on UTSOnline – Conduct a literature search using the… 1 answer below » April 19, 2021/in Uncategorized /by admin Choose a topic from the list provided on UTSOnline • Conduct a literature search using the appropriate databases (e.g. PubMed) and keywords to find current, relevant, peer-reviewed scientific articles on your topic. • Critically read these scientific articles. Use the points below to help guide what kind of content should be in the article. Other high-quality content relevant to your article will be rewarded. 1. The significance and impact of the microorganism(s) in human or animal health, industry or to the environment e.g. value and/or cost to society, value to industry or value to the environment (e.g. nutrient cycling). Use this to focus your article on an angle that relates to a broad audience. 2. If your microorganism(s) is: a. a pathogen – information on its disease process, transmission and control methods b. an industrially relevant microorganism(s) – commercial products that are made, the industrial processes used to produce these product(s) and the physical parameters that are required to allow the microorganism(s) to thrive (e.g. temperature) c. an environmentally-relevant microorganism(s) – environmental process(es) the microorganism(s) is involved in and the physical parameters that are required to allow the microorganism(s) to thrive (e.g. temperature) 3. Other information might include: a. a full taxonomic classification of the microorganism(s) b. the microorganism(s) natural host(s) and/or environments c. the methods of identification or detection of the microorganism(s) In your own words, synthesise this scientific information to tell a story in the format of a magazinestyle article (see modules on UTSOnline). You will need to critically evaluate the literature, draw conclusions and make recommendations. Consider your audience and purpose. Attachments: Magazine-Styl….pdf 91314-SemAssi….pdf Magazine-Styl….pdf 91314-GM-Week….docx Example-1.pdf   "Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!" https://graduatepaperhelp.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/logo-300x75-1.png 0 0 admin https://graduatepaperhelp.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/logo-300x75-1.png admin2021-04-19 14:18:552021-04-19 14:18:55Choose a topic from the list provided on UTSOnline - Conduct a literature search using the... 1 answer below » If a student borrows $20,000 to start a business as a 5 year, 10% loan, assume annual payments, the April 19, 2021/in Uncategorized /by admin If a student borrows $20,000 to start a business as a 5 year, 10% loan, assume annual payments, the decrease in principal in year 1 isa. $2,000.00b. $3,275.95c. $4,000.00d. $5,275.95e. None of these   "Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!" https://graduatepaperhelp.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/logo-300x75-1.png 0 0 admin https://graduatepaperhelp.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/logo-300x75-1.png admin2021-04-19 14:17:432021-04-19 14:17:43If a student borrows $20,000 to start a business as a 5 year, 10% loan, assume annual payments, the You are a consultant in a community of around 4,000 people. The city council has asked you to create April 19, 2021/in Uncategorized /by admin You are a consultant in a community of around 4,000 people. The city council has asked you to create an anti-litter campaign to assist the clean-up of their community. Since you believe that litter can be controlled by cognitive, social, and technological means, outline the different steps you would take in evaluating the community, why there is litter, and what you can do to assist in building the anti-litter campaign for the city council. How would your means be effective?   Your response should be at least 200 words in length. Posted: 4 years ago Due: 04/12/2015 Budget: $3   "Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!" https://graduatepaperhelp.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/logo-300x75-1.png 0 0 admin https://graduatepaperhelp.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/logo-300x75-1.png admin2021-04-19 14:15:312021-04-19 14:15:31You are a consultant in a community of around 4,000 people. The city council has asked you to create Our Company We are a leading academic writing company, which has been providing exclusive writing services for years. With an exceptional team of professional academic experts in a wide range of subjects, we guarantee high-quality custom-written papers. Writing Services Admission Services Custom Essays Term Papers Case Studies Research Proposals Bibliographies Dissertation Services How to format a research paper in APA format How to format Research Paper in Chicago format Style How to Write a Research Paper in Harvard How to Write a Research Paper in IEEE Format How to write a research paper in MLA format DISCLAIMER The reference papers provided by graduatepaperhelp.com serve as model papers for students and are not to be submitted as it is. These papers are intended to be used for research and reference purposes only Scroll to top Hi there! Click one of our representatives below and we will get back to you as soon as possible. Graduate paper help Customer support Chat with us on WhatsApp Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Part 4 Form 1040 Schedule C Schedule E Form 8962